By Dana Dorrity
James Mangold’s new film 3:10 to Yuma, based on an Elmore Leonard story and a 1957 western of the same name, is both an homage to many of the masterpieces of this genre and a contemporary classic in its own right. Leonard, who is usually associated with hip, urban dramas like Jackie Brown, Out of Sight, and Get Shorty, is getting much of the credit for the memorable, poetic dialogue and the well-drawn characters. The conflict and the rapport between the lawman and the prisoner are set up in his original short story. But in Leonard’s terse 14-pages, originally published in 1953 in Dime Western Magazine and currently available in the book, “The Complete Western Stories of Elmore Leonard,” the story begins in Contention, Arizona, where the two men, a deputy named Paul Scallen and an outlaw named Jim Kidd, wait in the Republic Hotel, room 207, to catch the 3:10 train to the Yuma prison, and ends two hours later with the face-off between the deputy and the killer’s gang of outlaws.
Expanding on the Original Story
The new film has expanded significantly on both the Leonard story and the 1953 black and white film. The 1953 screenplay, by television writer Halstead Welles, opens when a poor rancher, Dan Evans (Van Heflin), out with his two sons trying to graze his cattle, accidentally stumbles upon Ben Wade (Glenn Ford) and his band of outlaws robbing the Butterfield Stagecoach. The newest version of the film starring Christian Bale as Evans and Russell Crowe as Wade, takes the story back another step to the night. The opening shot pays tribute to Leonard’s early western stories. In the scene, Dan’s son, Will Evans (Logan Lerman), is laying in bed reading Dime Western Magazine, when he hears men approaching outside. Although his father is ready and waiting with a rifle, when the men who work for the local moneylender set the barn on fire, Evans, a law-abiding citizen, refuses to fight back. This sets up a powerful secondary conflict between the father and son in the 2007 screenplay written by Michael Brandt and Derek Haas.
What Westerns Are About
Westerns are about cowboys, Indians, loose women and gunfighters; and the great, classic Western films have all of these characters, but at the core, the Western genre is about the taming of the Wild West which is usually personified by a single criminal who refuses to live within the bounds of the law. The Western, as a genre in film or literature, is set in the decades after the American Civil War, when Union and Confederate Veterans were going west to seek cheap farmland and new opportunities. Until this moment, the Western towns were places that were barely governed.